Guides · Office

How much does auto repair shop insurance cost?

Your insurance bill went up again, and you're not sure if it's normal or if you're overpaying. Here's how Nolavi works through it, the same way a good mechanic works on a car: find the concern, the cause, the correction, then verify the fix.

1

The concern

Nate's insurance renew came in at $18,400 a year, up $3,200 from the year before. He didn't know if that was high for a five bay shop or not, and he had no way to see how it affected what he needed to charge per hour.

Table of auto repair shop insurance policies with annual costs showing an umbrella policy with overlapping coverage
One policy was covering what another already covered.
2

The cause

Nolavi pulled his last three years of insurance bills and compared them to his revenue and number of bays. His general liability and garagekeepers premiums had both increased, and one of his policies had duplicate coverage with another. His labor rate hadn't changed to match the higher cost.

Nolavi labor rate alert showing an auto repair shop needs to raise its rate after insurance cost increased
Caught at renewal, not at year end.
3

The correction

Nolavi logged the new annual cost and recalculated the labor rate he needed to hit his profit goal. It flagged the duplicate coverage so he could ask his broker. The labor rate health check showed him exactly where he stood against his cost every week, not just at renewal time.

4

The verification

He removed the duplicate coverage and saved $1,100. His new labor rate of $149 was still below the area average. Parts profit and payroll held. Net profit rose from 9% to 12% over the next quarter.

Auto repair shop results after adjusting labor rate for insurance cost and removing duplicate coverage
The cost went up. The profit went up more.

How we work. We make changes like this for shops all the time, using each shop's own data. The numbers shown are examples.

Auto repair shop coaching from your own numbers. Nolavi sends a plain report every Monday with the moves worth making next. See how it works

Questions

Quick answers.

How much does auto repair shop insurance cost?

A five bay independent shop typically pays $12,000 to $25,000 a year for general liability and garagekeepers combined. The range is wide because it depends on revenue, location, claims history and how many vehicles you work on. The number matters most when you use it to set your labor rate.

What insurance does an auto repair shop need?

At minimum: general liability, garagekeepers liability (for customer vehicles in your care), and workers compensation. Many shops add commercial property and a business owners policy. Nolavi tracks each one as a bill and feeds the cost into your labor rate calculation automatically.

Keep reading

See it for yourself.

Open the demo and find this kind of problem in a minute. Or book your 14 day free trial: it starts with a quick call, and we set it all up and fit it to your shop.

Try the live demo